The Heat Signal: Economic Reality, Narrative Drift, and the Crisis of Identity in Commercial Infrared Earth Observation

Written By Adam Simmons

The Thermodynamics of Value

The commercial Earth observation (EO) sector currently stands at a precarious inflection point in 2026. For over a decade, the industry has been dominated by a "visual" paradigm, optical imagery that answers the question of what the Earth looks like. Companies like Planet and Vantor (previously Maxar) built empires on the premise that seeing the planet in visible light, with increasing frequency and resolution, would unlock infinite commercial value. Yet, as the market matures, a more profound realization is taking hold: the most economically and physically significant signal the planet emits is not its appearance, but its energy.

Heat, combustion, thermal loss, industrial throughput, urban stress, and power generation are thermodynamic phenomena, not optical ones. They are invisible to the standard camera sensors that have saturated the market. They are captured only through infrared (thermal) sensing, the modality that measures what the planet is doing. This shift from observation of form to observation of function represents the next great frontier in geospatial intelligence. It promises to turn EO from a static mapping exercise into a dynamic instrument of economic monitoring, capable of verifying industrial activity, predicting commodity flows, and unmasking the operational reality of the global economy, particularly during the "blind" hours of the night.

However, despite the immense strategic potential of high-resolution thermal infrared (TIR) data, the nascent sector is struggling to articulate its value proposition. A disconnect exists between the hard commercial utility of thermal data, specifically its ability to monitor the "night-time economy" and industrial output, and the soft, often nebulous "climate" narratives that companies use to position themselves.

This report offers an exhaustive critique of the current state of the Infrared Satellite Imaging Industry. It utilizes SatVu as a primary exemplar of the sector’s strategic dichotomy: a company possessing category-defining technology yet burdened by a marketing strategy that obscures its strongest competitive advantages. Furthermore, it analyzes the recent, seismic shift by Albedo Space, which exited the commercial imagery market in late 2025 to focus on hardware sales, as a bellwether event that exposes the fragility of the "pixels-as-a-product" business model.

The analysis indicates that while the physics of thermal EO are undeniable, the economics of the sector remain unproven. To survive, the industry must pivot from performative environmentalism to ruthless operational intelligence, acknowledging a fundamental truth: the planet’s real economy runs on energy, and energy is best observed when the lights go out.

Beyond the Optical Bias: The Physics of "Truth"

The Invisible Economy

For most of the commercial EO industry's history, "vision" has been synonymous with "light." High-resolution optical imagery dominates the market narrative, providing glossy pictures, change detection algorithms, and digital twins of cities. Radar (SAR) has carved out a complementary niche, offering all-weather structural insight. SAR has and is growing significantly as its true value is recognized. Together, these modalities define the baseline of planetary observation.

However, optical and radar systems share a common limitation: they measure structure and reflectance. They can tell an analyst that a factory exists, that a ship is in port, or that a cooling tower is standing. They cannot, however, definitively tell an analyst if the factory is running, if the ship's engines are warm, or if the cooling tower is venting heat. They see the shell of the economy, not its pulse.

Infrared sensing inverts this paradigm. By detecting emitted radiation in the mid-wave (MWIR) and long-wave (LWIR) infrared bands, thermal sensors measure the kinetic temperature of objects. This data is not a proxy for activity; it is a direct measurement of the energy conversion that drives economic output. In an industrial civilization, economic activity is inextricably linked to heat generation. Steel blast furnaces, data center cooling systems, catalytic crackers at oil refineries, and concrete curing processes all possess distinct thermal signatures that serve as irrefutable proof of operation.

The Public Baseline and the Commercial Ceiling

Infrared EO is not a new domain. It has been foundational in climate science and meteorology for decades, supported by a "public thermal stack" of government missions. These systems define the "ceiling" for commercial entrants. Because government data is scientifically validated and free, commercial players cannot compete on "thermal data" broadly. They must compete on spatiotemporal resolution. The commercial value lies in answering the questions that Landsat cannot: "What is the thermal signature of this specific building at 2:00 AM?"

Mission Operator Res (Thermal) Revisit Primary Use Case Commercial Limitation
Landsat 8/9 NASA/USGS ~100m 16 Days Climate, Agriculture Too coarse for asset monitoring; infrequent revisit.
Sentinel-3 ESA ~1km Daily Ocean/Land Temp Macro-level monitoring; insufficient for industrial intelligence.
ECOSTRESS NASA (ISS) ~70m Variable Plant Stress, Urban Heat Experimental platform; orbit dependent on ISS.
MODIS/VIIRS NASA/NOAA 375m - 1km Daily Fire, Weather Low resolution; primarily for large-scale anomaly detection.

The emergence of companies like SatVu, OroraTech, Hydrosat, and Constellr marks the transition of thermal EO from a scientific discipline to commercial infrastructure. These actors are not trying to replicate Landsat; they are attempting to operationalize thermal data by increasing revisit rates (temporal resolution) and sharpening the image (spatial resolution) to a level where asset-specific intelligence becomes possible.

The Physics of "Truth"

The unique value of thermal data lies in its resistance to deception. In the optical domain, camouflage, decoys, and "lights-out" operations can fool sensors. In the thermal domain, thermodynamics prevents such obfuscation. An active engine must reject heat. A living plant must transpire. A data center processing AI workloads must cool its servers.

This "thermodynamic truth" is the sector's strongest asset. As verifying environmental, social, and governance (ESG) claims becomes regulatory practice, and as verifying industrial output becomes central to commodities trading, the ability to independently measure Infrared energy becomes a proxy for "truth" in global markets. SatVu's recent release of thermal imagery showing a Bitcoin mining facility in Rockdale, Texas, reveals the cooling systems and high-load infrastructure in a way optical imagery never could. This is not just a picture; it is an energy audit from space.

The Night-Time Economy: A Trillion Dollar Blind Spot

The Economic Centrality of Darkness

A critical strategic failure in the current marketing of infrared EO is the under-leveraging of the "night-time economy." Thermal imaging is inherently powerful at night, not merely because it acts as "night vision," but because darkness removes solar loading (optical noise). Without the sun heating the Earth's surface, sensors measure emitted energy directly.

The economic implications of this are staggering. Power grids often reach peak loads or sustain critical base loads through the night. Industrial operations such as refineries, smelters, and chemical plants operate on 24/7 continuous cycles. Logistics hubs, including ports and rail yards, increasingly utilize off-peak hours to move freight to avoid congestion. Data centers, the backbone of the digital economy, run continuously, and their cooling signatures are often most distinct against the cooler ambient background of night.

Roughly half of the physical economy operates under conditions where optical satellites are functionally blind. SAR can see through the dark, but it sees texture, not activity. Only thermal sensors can visualize the intensity of night-time operations.

The Market SatVu Should Own

SatVu sits in a near-unique position to exploit this insight. Its HotSat constellation is designed for high-resolution MWIR capture, day and night. The critique of the industry's positioning suggests that SatVu’s marketing treats night-time capability as a "feature" rather than a "category-defining advantage".

By failing to aggressively frame itself as the "owner" of the night-time economy, the industry cedes ground. The night-time economy is not just about counting streetlights (which VIIRS does); it is about measuring industrial throughput when no one is looking. Traders need to know if a refinery is running at capacity during the night shift. Optical satellites cannot see this. Thermal can. Compliance monitoring for illegal flaring, unauthorized discharge of effluent water (which SatVu has demonstrated capabilities to detect 9), and factory operations during mandated shutdowns often occur at night to avoid detection.

The ability to image the world when the lights go out is not a technical specification; it is a strategic moat. In a market crowded with daytime optical sensors, the "night" is blue-ocean territory. The reluctance of companies like SatVu to center their narrative on this dominance is a puzzling strategic oversight.

SatVu: The Exemplar of Strategic Paradox

Technical Excellence, Narrative Confusion

SatVu, a London-based thermal imaging company, serves as the perfect case study for the industry's broader struggles. Technically, the company is a pioneer. Its pathfinder satellite, HotSat-1, launched in 2023, delivered 3.5m resolution thermal video and still imagery. This resolution is a quantum leap over the 100m baseline of Landsat, allowing for the inspection of individual buildings, trains, and industrial units.

Despite the premature failure of HotSat-1's sensor after six months, the data validated the technology. SatVu successfully imaged the thermal footprint of the Al Zour refinery in Kuwait, detecting a fire incident, and monitored activity at North Korea's Yongbyon Nuclear Scientific Research Center. These are high-value, "hard" intelligence products.

However, a review of SatVu’s public messaging reveals a "confused story". The company’s dominant narrative leans heavily into climate. Phrases like "COP30 exposed the gaps in climate observation", "We will give everyone access to thermal intelligence for a safer and more sustainable Earth", and "Advancing Climate Action" permeate their communications.

While directionally noble, "Climate" is a notoriously difficult commercial market. Procurement cycles are long, budgets are diffuse, and willingness to pay for premium data is low compared to defense or finance. By framing itself primarily as a climate actor, SatVu risks "hiding a hard commercial product inside a soft moral story".

The "Capability Gap" vs. The "Coverage Gap"

SatVu’s COP30 messaging argues that the world has a "capability gap", we can see where assets are (coverage), but not what they are doing (capability). This is a strong intellectual argument, but it is often deployed in the service of "verifying emissions" or "monitoring urban heat islands."

While urban heat mapping is socially valuable, as demonstrated by their work in Darwin, Australia, mapping heat stress, it is not a recurring revenue engine in the same way that monitoring global crude oil storage or semiconductor manufacturing output is. Cities buy a heat map once every few years; commodities traders buy refinery data every day.

The critique highlights that SatVu’s marketing lacks a "quantified marketing study". There are case studies, but few benchmarks against public baselines or detection rate metrics that a hedge fund or intelligence agency would require. In a sector where the alternative (Landsat/Sentinel) is free, credibility comes from quantification, not aesthetics.

A Shift to "Sovereign-Grade" Intelligence?

Recent developments suggest SatVu is beginning to correct this alignment. In late 2025 and early 2026, the company began emphasizing "National Security" and "Economic Monitoring" more heavily.

  • Defense Contracts: SatVu secured a contract to support NATO’s space-based intelligence and joined the NGA’s Luno A & B consortium.

  • Partnerships: A major collaboration with IHI Corporation in Japan to develop a sovereign thermal constellation.

  • Personnel: The hiring of Scott Herman, a national security veteran, as CTO in Jan 2026 signals a pivot toward "sovereign-grade thermal intelligence".

This shift indicates that the company is waking up to the reality that Defense and Intelligence (D&I) are the true anchor tenants of the EO market, accounting for ~50% of revenue. The "Climate" narrative may remain for public relations, but the "Defense" narrative is paying the bills.

Feature Climate Narrative (Current) Infrastructure Intelligence (Required)
Core Value "Resilience," "Sustainability," "Emissions" "Verification," "Throughput," "Security"
Key Buyer Gov Environmental Agencies, NGOs Hedge Funds, Defense Intelligence, Energy Traders
Buying Cycle Long, grant-dependent, bureaucratic Fast, Recurring, High WTP
Data Use Annual/Monthly, Strategic Planning Daily/Hourly Monitoring, Tactical Alpha
Night-Time "Urban Heat Island monitoring" "Stealth activity detection," "Output verification"

The HotSat Roadmap

SatVu is aggressively expanding despite the loss of HotSat-1. The company has signed contracts for HotSat-2 and HotSat-3, with launches scheduled for 2025. Secured funding of £20 million (equity + insurance payout) is fueling this build. The goal remains a constellation capable of high-frequency revisit, which is essential for the "monitoring" use case. A single satellite takes a picture; a constellation monitors a process.

The Hardware Pivot: Albedo as the Canary in the Coal Mine

The Pivot: Abandoning the Pixel

Perhaps the most significant signal of the EO market's structural difficulties comes from Albedo Space. In October 2025, Albedo made a shocking announcement: it was dropping its commercial imagery business entirely to focus on building and selling satellite buses for the Very Low Earth Orbit (VLEO) regime.

Albedo had been one of the most hyped startups in the sector, promising 10cm optical and 2m thermal imagery from VLEO, resolutions previously reserved for classified government assets. Investors and analysts viewed them as the next "Planet" or "Vantor."

Why Hardware Beat Data

The decision to pivot was driven by the on-orbit performance of their first satellite, Clarity-1, launched in March 2025.

  • The VLEO Breakthrough: Operating in VLEO (approx. 275km altitude) is notoriously difficult due to atmospheric drag and atomic oxygen, which degrades spacecraft surfaces.

  • Performance Beat: Clarity-1’s bus demonstrated a drag coefficient 12% better than design targets and proved it could survive the atomic oxygen environment, validating a 5-year lifespan.

  • The Business Case: Albedo realized that the value of their proprietary VLEO platform (the hardware that allows sustained operation at that altitude) exceeded the potential value of selling the images it collected.

The "Data Trap"

Albedo’s exit from the imagery market is a damning indictment of the "Data-as-a-Service" model in EO. Selling pixels is a brutal business. Optical imagery is increasingly commoditized, with prices falling as supply increases. Selling data requires massive sales teams, complex licensing, and cloud infrastructure to deliver petabytes of pixels to customers who often lack the expertise to use them. Furthermore, the cost of customer acquisition in the commercial sector (insurance, finance) is high, and adoption is slower than VC timelines demand.

By pivoting to hardware, Albedo moves "upstream." They are no longer competing with Planet or SatVu to sell JPEGs to hedge funds; they are selling the "picks and shovels" (VLEO buses) to the Defense Department and other operators who want to fly their own sensors. This shifts their revenue model from low-margin, high-volume data sales to high-margin, high-value hardware contracts, a model that aligns better with the current dominance of government spending in the space sector

Implications for SatVu and Others

Albedo’s move casts a shadow over the infrared sector. It suggests that "having the best resolution" (which Albedo had) is not enough to guarantee a viable data business. SatVu, which is still betting on the "sell the pixels" model, must take note. If Albedo, with 10cm resolution, couldn't make the math work, SatVu faces immense pressure to prove that thermal pixels are sufficiently differentiated from optical pixels to command the premium pricing necessary to sustain a constellation.

The Vertical Specialists: Where the Money Is

While SatVu pursues a "horizontal" strategy (building a thermometer for the whole world), other players are finding traction by going "vertical", solving specific problems for specific industries.

OroraTech: The Firefighters

OroraTech has emerged as the leader in the wildfire vertical. Unlike SatVu, which markets "thermal intelligence" broadly, OroraTech sells a "Wildfire Solution". Their customers (forestry services, insurers, governments) have an immediate, burning platform (literally). They don't want "data"; they want an alert on a dashboard that says "Fire detected at coordinates X, Y."

They have secured significant contracts (e.g., €20M with the Greek government) and are expanding to a 100+ satellite constellation. They are successfully selling "answers" (alerts/risk modeling), not just pixels. Their Series B extension (€25M in late 2024/early 2025) validates investor confidence in this vertical approach.

Hydrosat: The Agronomists

Hydrosat focuses entirely on water stress and agriculture. They use thermal to measure Land Surface Temperature (LST) as a proxy for crop stress and irrigation needs. By acquiring IrriWatch, Hydrosat moved downstream, offering a software product for farmers rather than just raw imagery. Their VanZyl-1 satellite launch (2024/2025) and subsequent $60M Series B (Jan 2026) demonstrate that the agriculture vertical, driven by water scarcity and food security, is a viable engine for growth.

Constellr: The Precision Analysts

Constellr occupies a similar niche to Hydrosat but with a focus on "precision" LST for the European market. Their SkyBee-1 launch (Jan 2025) and contracts with the European Commission (Copernicus Contributing Mission) highlight the strong institutional support for thermal data in Europe. Their marketing is "scientifically rigorous," appealing to the technical buyer, but perhaps lacking the emotive urgency of OroraTech’s wildfire narrative.

Muon Space / FireSat: The Institutional Play

Muon Space is taking a different tack with FireSat, a purpose-built constellation for wildfire monitoring developed in partnership with the non-profit Earth Fire Alliance. Supported by Google and the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation, FireSat represents a hybrid model: philanthropic and institutional capital funding a mission with global public utility. This insulates Muon Space somewhat from the immediate pressure of finding commercial buyers, allowing them to focus on the "mission" of climate resilience with credible backing.

The Divergence

The market is splitting into two distinct camps:

  1. The Verticalists (OroraTech, Hydrosat): Deep integration into specific workflows (fire, farming). They are essentially software companies that own satellites.

  2. The Horizontalists (SatVu): Providing a broad "thermal layer" for defense, energy, and infrastructure. This is higher risk but potentially higher reward if they can become the "Bloomberg Terminal" of thermal heat signatures.

Company Core Strategy Primary Vertical Key Recent Milestone Strategic Risk
SatVu Horizontal Defense, Energy, Climate HotSat-2/3 contracts; IHI partnership Identity crisis (Climate vs. Intel); Data commoditization
OroraTech Vertical Wildfire, Forestry €25M Series B ext; 100+ sat constellation plan Limited TAM outside of wildfire season?
Hydrosat Vertical Agriculture, Water $60M Series B; VanZyl-1 Success Dependence on ag-tech adoption rates
Constellr Vertical Ag, Climate Risk SkyBee-1 Launch; Copernicus Contract Competition with Hydrosat/Public data
Albedo Pivot Defense, Operators Exit from Imagery; Clarity-1 VLEO success Hardware is CAPEX intensive; single-failure risks

The Commercial Reality: Buyers, Friction, and the "Holy Grail"

The Hedge Fund Mirage?

For years, the "holy grail" of commercial EO was the financial sector. Hedge funds were supposed to devour satellite data to trade commodities. The reality has been slower and more difficult than hyped. "Opaque and fragmented" data, lack of standardization, and the "trust deficit" have hindered widespread adoption.

However, thermal data offers something optical didn't: insider knowledge of industrial rates. Shadows on floating roof tanks (optical) can estimate volume, but thermal can see the temperature of the tank, revealing turnover rates and refining activity. Wood Mackenzie’s "Refinery Intelligence" already uses infrared to monitor shutdowns and startups. SatVu is attempting to displace these ground/aerial sensors with space-based coverage. Recent wins, such as SatVu’s €1M ESA Marketplace support for an energy sector project (Jan 2025), suggest they are finally cracking this code, partnering with a "major energy trader" to scale operations.

Defense as the Anchor

Despite the commercial hype, the "Outlook for 2025/2026" remains dominated by government spending. Governments want their own eyes in the sky. The IHI partnership in Japan is a prime example of "sovereign capability" development. The war in Ukraine and rising geopolitical tensions have made "monitoring industrial capacity" a national security issue. Knowing if an adversary's steel plant is running a third shift is intelligence data. The market is consolidating, with large defense primes and established players looking to acquire capability. Albedo’s shift to selling buses feeds directly into this, primes want flight-proven hardware to launch their own secret sensors.

The Night-Time Gap in Finance

The night-time economy remains the untapped frontier for finance. Night lights (VIIRS) are already used as proxies for GDP and economic activity. Moving from "blob of light" (VIIRS) to "heat signature of a specific factory" (SatVu) allows for micro-economic nowcasting. An analyst could theoretically track the nightly output of a specific Tesla Gigafactory or a specific Foxconn plant. This is the product that SatVu should be selling to Wall Street, rather than "climate resilience."

Strategic Outlook: 2026 and Beyond

The Crisis of Identity

The Infrared Satellite Imaging Industry is suffering from an identity crisis. Is it a climate savior? A spy tool? A stock market ticker? The "Climate Trap", framing thermal primarily as a climate tool, is a strategic error. It aligns the product with slow-moving, bureaucratic budgets. The reality is that thermal is an infrastructure intelligence tool. It measures the metabolism of the industrial world.

Recommendations for the Sector

  1. Own the Night: Companies like SatVu must pivot their marketing to dominate the night-time economy narrative. "We see what the world does while it sleeps" is a more compelling value proposition for intelligence and finance than "we monitor urban heat islands."

  2. Quantify the Value: The sector needs rigorous studies showing the alpha generated by thermal data. "Our data predicted the oil price spike 3 days early because we saw the refinery overheat."

  3. Hardware or Data? Choose One. Albedo’s pivot proves that trying to do both is dangerous. Companies must decide if they are infrastructure providers (selling buses/sensors) or intelligence providers (selling answers).

  4. Embrace the "Dark" Arts: "Dark Vessel Detection," "Industrial Espionage" (legal), and "Compliance Monitoring" are the killer apps. The industry should stop shying away from the aggressive, surveillance-heavy nature of its technology.

  5. Recognize how it compliments SAR. Maximizing the sensor's potential will get you 70% there…but often with analysis the power comes in how you can augment your weaknesses. Infrared has its own disadvantages in collection and image anomalies. By exemplifying how IR can be mixed with SAR you show the full story for your customers.

The potential of the infrared industry is immense. We are moving from a world where we guess at economic activity to one where we can measure it directly, in joules and kelvins. But the path to profitability is littered with failed business models and confused narratives.

Albedo’s exit from the imagery market is a warning shot: the physics of VLEO are easier to master than the economics of selling pixels. For SatVu and its peers, the challenge in 2026 is not to launch more satellites, but to launch a more honest story, one that admits that in a volatile world, the most valuable commodity is not a picture of the Earth, but the heat signature of its engine. The companies that can verify the "ground truth" of the global economy, day or night, will define the next decade of geospatial intelligence. Those that remain trapped in the soft focus of "climate observation" may find themselves, like Albedo's former imagery business, left out in the cold.

Adam Simmons
Next

The Price of Neglect: Assessing the Consequences of Underfunding Earth Measurement